Errors on the net

Part of Peter Krafft’s family tree

Additional Ikin children

Above is a page from the web site hosted by gencircles submitted by Peter Krafft some years ago. While Peter has done a great job creating his family tree on gencircles, he has also included some entries that are incorrect. I drew his attention to the following three entries in 2006 but as at 3 April 2010 all three remain listed as children of Obadiah and Sarah Ikin.

Jane Ikin born 1787 in England, died 1822, St Lukes, Liverpool, Sydney
Ann Ikin born 1804, died 1855, Camperdown, Newtown
James Ikin born 1806 in Sydney, NSW, died 1840, Parramatta

In my view none of them are children of Obadiah and Sarah Ikin.

Jane Ikin, died 1822, Liverpool

At that time in Liverpool there lived a family named SKIN or SKINN and their surname has been confused with IKIN on a number of occasions and this is one of them. The online NSW births, death and marriages indexes lists Jane under Ikin.

I have a book put out by the Liverpool Council on burials in the first cemetery (St Lukes) and she is listed under Skin – died 30 June 1822, aged 35 years. Also listed is Charles Skin, died 20 June 1822 aged one year. In the online NSW births, death and marriages indexes, Charles is also found under Ikin with parents William and Jane. The same index reveals that William Skinn married Jane Host in 1815, and that Charles Skin was baptised in 1821.

There are no Ikin entries in the St Lukes, Liverpool cemetery list.

James Ikin, d 1840 Parramatta

This man is a convict who arrived on the ship Camden in 1831. He received a Ticket of Leave passport on 28 November 1836 on the recommendation of the Penrith bench, see NSW State Records web site. The book General Return of Convicts in New South Wales 1837 lists James Ikins, aged 30 years, ship Prince Regent 1830, Cassilis, T of L. In 1830 the ship Prince Regent arrived in Hobart and there is no James Ikin(s) listed as being on this ship. Also the State Library of Queensland web site listing convicts extracted from HO 11 states James arrived on the ship Camden in 1831.

Ann Ikin b 1804 d 1855 Camperdown

I am reasonably certain that this is Ann Jones who married the other Ikin convict, Joseph Ikin in 1848, see the online NSW births, death and marriages indexes. Joseph Ikin arrived in Sydney on the ship York on 7 February 1831, he was 35 years, a native of Cheshire. Joseph married Ann Jones on 17 January 1848 at Windsor, NSW. They dont appear to have had any children. Ann Ikin died on 11 March 1855 aged 51 years.

There is no evidence that Obadiah and Sarah had children Jane, Ann or James. If they had then you would have thought they would have appeared in such records as the 1822 Muster and 1828 Census, and possibly Sarah’s will.

_________________________________________________________________________

On ancestry.org there is a large tree that includes a page for Maria Ikin which has many errors –

the owner is ikinmoore1957. Also there are errors on other pages that I wont list here.

In the Profile for Maria Ikin

Delete entry: 1792 “St Thomas Cemetery” from birth

Add entry: birth of brother Obediah Joseph Ikin 1782

Add entry: birth of sister Marianne/Mary 1784

Add entry: birth of brother William Ikin 1785

Add entry: birth of sister Mary Ann Ikin 1788

Add entry: birth of brother Alexander Ikin 1789

Delete entry: birth of sister Ann Ikin 1804 not child of Obadiah Ikin

Delete entry: birth of brother James Ikin 1806 not child of Obadiah Ikin

Delete entry: death of father Obadiah Ikin 1810 – date and year of death is unknown

Add entry: birth of daughter Agnes Sarah Leyne 1812

Delete entry: 1812 marriage to Richard Leyne – Maria did not marry Richard Leyne

Delete entry: 1814 residence Windsor – continually resided on Church Hill, Sydney

Delete entry: 1822 death of sister Jane Ikin – Maria did not have a sister Jane Ikin

Delete entry: 1834 marriage to E.T.Y.W. McDonald – this man is Maria’s son-in-law

Delete entry: 1835 birth of son David McDonald – not Maria’s child

Delete entry: 1839 birth of daughter Agnes McDonald – not Maria’s child

Delete two entries: 1839 death of sister Mary Ann Ikin– conflicting information and unproven dates

Delete entry: 1840 death of brother James Ikin – Obadiah Ikin does not have a child James Ikin

Delete entry: 1841 birth of daughter Frances McDonald – not Maria’s child

Delete entry: 1844 death of daughter Frances McDonald – not Maria’s child

Delete entry: 1844 birth of son Edward McDonald – not Maria’s child

Delete entry: 1849 death of sister Elizabeth Ikin – not Maria’s sister

Delete entry: 1855 death of sister Ann Ikin – not Maria’s sister

Delete entry: 1855 death of son Edward McDonald – not Maria’s child

Delete entry: 1866 death of husband E T Y W McDonald – not Maria’s husband

___________________________________________________________________________

These errors also appear in other people’s family histories on such sites as rootsweb site.